top of page

Not Every Good Idea Is a Viable Business

Writer: Carolyn Rosenberg
Carolyn Rosenberg
Oct 15
5 min read
Product design workspace featuring a sketchbook with handbag drawings, fabric swatches, notebooks and a laptop arranged on a desk in warm, neutral tones.

How to assess whether a product has commercial potential before investing substantial money.


When I first decided to start my own business, I knew I wanted to develop physical products, but I didn't have any idea what those products would be.


I began researching an idea that interested me, investigating suppliers and manufacturing possibilities. It was something I could see potential in, but obtaining the information I needed was proving difficult. I haven't ruled out pursuing it in the future, but while I was researching it, a moment took place that sparked an entirely different idea.


My daughter had been working backstage at a dance concert and came home frustrated by the disorganisation she'd encountered. Parents hadn't brought everything their children needed and belongings weren't labelled making finding necesities backstage difficult. Having been involved in the dance industry for many years, I knew exactly what she was talking about.


That conversation led to the idea for DanseMÈRE.


Recognising a gap in the market


One of the advantages I had was my experience in the dance industry as a performer, teacher, school owner and dance mum. I understood the backstage environment at performances and competitions, including the chaos dancers often have to navigate.


But recognising a problem doesn't necessarily mean you've found a commercially viable business opportunity. I started researching what was already available, looking online and through social media at the products dancers were using. There were bags designed specifically for costumes, but I couldn't find anything that addressed the problem I wanted to solve.


That was encouraging, although finding a gap in the market doesn't automatically mean there's a market for your product. You still need to establish whether enough people recognise the problem and would be prepared to pay for a solution. Sometimes people don't even realise there's a problem until someone draws their attention to it or shows them a better way of doing something. That's where effective marketing can play an important role.


Because I was developing an original design, I needed to be careful about how much information I shared publicly. I spoke with friends and people I knew within the dance industry, sharing the concept with a small number of trusted people. Their feedback was positive, and I knew from my own experience that it was something I would have purchased when my daughter was dancing.


Of course, there's a difference between someone saying they love your idea and actually purchasing the finished product. With DanseMÈRE, there's also the added consideration that the person using the product isn't necessarily the person buying it. A dancer might immediately recognise its benefits, but it's often a parent making the purchasing decision.


These were all things I needed to consider when assessing whether the idea was worth pursuing.


Different products require different research


My second business, Leielle, came about quite differently. I'd spent a long time looking for a deodorant that met my own requirements and hadn't found anything that offered everything I wanted. That resulted in me investigating the market, looking at existing products, their ingredients and what consumers were saying about them.


Deodorant is used by a much broader population than a specialised dance bag. Although Leielle is being developed with a particular group of women in mind, I was able to conduct broader consumer research because the product itself is something most people are familiar with. I also spoke with formulation specialists and manufacturers to understand what might be possible, and conducted a consumer survey to learn more about other women's experiences and preferences.


A survey was a useful approach for Leielle because I could ask questions about existing products and what women wanted without revealing anything confidential about what I was developing. That wouldn't necessarily have worked as well for DanseMÈRE, where I needed to be more selective about who I shared the design with.


I don't believe there's one method of validating a product idea that works for every business. The research you undertake needs to suit the product, the market and the information you're trying to establish. What matters is obtaining enough information to make an informed decision about whether to proceed.


Understanding the financial commitment


Having previously been involved in product manufacturing through my employment, I already understood that bringing a physical product to market involves considerably more than the cost of manufacturing it.


I know there are people out there who have built million-dollar businesses after starting with just $1,000 and working from their kitchen table. It's certainly possible, but I don't believe that's the typical experience.


You need to consider design and development expenses, prototypes, packaging, freight, insurance, marketing and potentially trademark registration, intellectual property protection and product testing. Then there are the costs associated with storing your stock and fulfilling orders. Depending on your business model, you might use a third-party logistics (3PL) provider or lease premises and manage fulfilment yourself, which may involve hiring pick-and-pack staff. There are also minimum order quantities to consider, which can mean committing to a substantial amount of stock before you've made your first sale.


The type of product you're developing makes a difference too. There's a significant distinction between sourcing an existing product and making a few alterations, and developing something entirely from your own design.


With DanseMÈRE, I started by engaging a designer through Upwork to turn my idea into 3D drawings. Although I'd previously been involved in product manufacturing, I'd never developed a bag before and didn't understand all the technical processes involved. I was learning the different roles as I went, including the distinction between creating drawings, preparing a manufacturing tech pack and the factory developing the patterns needed to produce the bag. Each stage involves additional costs, and when you're developing something new, you should expect that changes and further samples may be necessary before the product is ready for production.


When it comes to pricing, it's important to distinguish between the initial investment in developing a product and the ongoing costs of producing and selling it. Design drawings, prototypes, tech packs and potentially moulds are development expenses, while your pricing needs to account for the cost of manufacturing each unit, including materials and labour, along with freight, storage, fulfilment and other operating expenses.


You need sufficient margin to cover those ongoing costs and make a profit, while also considering how the business will recover its initial development investment over time. A product might solve a problem, receive positive feedback and look promising, but if the numbers don't work, it's going to be difficult to build a sustainable business around it.


Knowing when to move forward


I was recently asked when I felt confident enough to start spending money developing my products. The truth is, I don't think you ever feel completely confident. You do your research, speak to people, investigate the possibilities and eventually make a decision based on the information you have.


With DanseMÈRE, my industry experience, market research and the feedback I'd received gave me enough encouragement to take the next step. With Leielle, I approached the research differently because the product and its potential customers were different. Neither approach guarantees success, and both products are still in development. There's more to learn, and their commercial potential will ultimately be tested when they reach the market.


I also don't believe product validation is something you do once and then forget about. As you move through development, you gather more information, refine your product, establish costs and continue assessing whether the opportunity makes commercial sense. There's always going to be some uncertainty involved in starting a business. Research can help reduce that uncertainty, but it can't eliminate it.


For me, the important thing is recognising that having a good idea is only the starting point. Before investing substantial money, you need to understand who your customers are, whether there's sufficient demand and what it will realistically cost to bring your product to market. You may never have all the answers, but the more you understand about the opportunity, the better equipped you are to decide whether it's worth pursuing.

 
 

Let's Connect

If you have an opportunity you'd like to discuss, I'd love to hear from you.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

© 2026 Carolyn Rosenberg

bottom of page